| Head of School and Principals | |||
| Mark Coté, Head of School | BA, Millersville University | MDiv, Regent University | |
| Sharon Brobst, Leola Campus Principal | BA, The King's College | MEd, Keene State College | |
| Sean Freund, West Lampeter Campus Principal | BA, Moody Bible Institute | MS, Baptist Bible College | |
| Leola Campus | |||
| Elementary | |||
| Christa Coté | Pre-K, 4-year olds | Assoc Degree, Harrisburg Area Community College | |
| Chris Doughty * | Kindergarten | BS, Millersville University | MEd, Azusa Pacific University |
| Deb Thomas | Grade 1 | BA, Eastern Mennonite University | |
| Alison Horst | Grade 2 | BA, Cedarville University | |
| Lori Cole* | Grade 3 | BS, Millersville University | |
| Alison Gerke | Grade 4 | BS, Penn State University | |
| Sylvia Beck | Grade 5 | BS, West Chester University | MEd, Millersville University |
| Megan Moffa | Functional Academic Curriculum & Skills (FACS) | BSE, Millersville University | |
| High School | |||
| Susan Bernhardt * | Directed Studies/Gifted | BS, Millersville University | |
| John Cashman * | English | BA, Boston College | MA, Temple University |
| Mark Coté | Honors Bible | BA, Millersville University | MDiv, Regent University |
| Lois Early | Discovery Center | BS, Millersville University | MEd, Lancaster Bible College |
| Matthew Hatcher * | Math | BA, State University of New York | MS, State University of New York |
| Michelle Hayden | Math/Visual Arts | BA in Art, Millersville University | BA in Psychology, Millersville University |
| Jessica Heindel | English | BA, Salem State University | |
| John Hildebrand * | Social Studies | BS, Millersville University | |
| Carol Lively | Visual Arts - elem & high school | BS, Indiana University of PA | |
| Nate Long | Social Studies | BSE, Millersville University | |
| Mike McCauley | Physical Education/Health | BS, Millersville University | |
| Tony Myers | Science | BS, Gannon University | |
| Diane Ramer | Spanish | BS, Indiana University of PA | |
| Becky Sprenkle * | Science | BS, Millersville University | |
| Anne Marie Walny | Bible | BA, Millersville University | MDiv, Regent University |
| Holly Wert | Music/Drama | BM, Marywood University | |
| Gail Workman | College & Career Counselor | BS, Millersville University | MLS, Kutztown University |
| West Lampeter Campus | |||
| UMS Elementary | |||
| Krista Guyer | Kindergarten | BSE, Millersville University | |
| Linda Imgrund | Grade 1 | BS, Philadelphia Biblical University | MEd, Millersville University |
| Lori Sparks | Grade 2 | BS, University of Delaware | |
| Tammi Dodson | Grade 3 | BS, Appalachian State University | |
| Alecia Weaver | Grade 4 | BS, Lancaster Bible College | |
| Erica Howard | Grade 5/6 (Math, Science, Bible) | BS, West Chester University | |
| Jodie Richardson * | Grade 5/6 (LA, Social Studies, Bible) | BS, Messiah College | |
| Middle School | |||
| Candace Arndt | English | BSE, Millersville University | |
| Linda Drake | Directed Studies, Discovery Center | BS, Baptist Bible College | |
| Bruce Hoover | Social Studies | BS, Millersville University | MS, Millersville University |
| Stephanie Randolph* | Bible | BS, Valley Forge Christian College | |
| Alison Thiemann | Math | BS in Education, Lancaster Bible College | BS in Bible, Lancaster Bible College |
| Both Campuses | |||
| Brian Bartch | Music | BA, Millersville University | |
| Doris Benedict | Spanish | BS, University of Inca Garcilaso de la Vega | |
| Renee Erich | Library & Media Center | BA, Penn State University | MLIS, University of Pittsburgh |
| Brian Fleetman* | Visual Arts/Tech/Yearbook | BFA, Edinboro University of PA | |
| Jenna Hege | Music | BS, Lancaster Bible College | |
| Ryan Martin | Physical Education/Health | BS in Education, Lancaster Bible College | BS in Bible, Lancaster Bible College |
| Steve Reaggs | Music/Tech | BM, Shenandoah University | |